Friday, October 31, 2008

Airport Security and the Japanese Internment

How many of you have wondered about the rationality of airport security agents abiding by anti-discrimination regulations when determining which airline passengers should be submitted to additional security screening? I have. I think it's ridiculous. To impose some kind of artificial quota on airport security so that for every passenger from Pakistan or Saudi Arabia who is required to undergo additional security screening they must also select one white person, one black person, one Hispanic, one elderly individual, and one college student to undergo the same screening is a joke, and I'll tell you why. For one thing, it imposes a fear of punishment on security personnel who know that if they suspect a passenger of Middle-Eastern origin (or whatever other minority ethnic group) as being a possible security risk then they know that should they act on their beliefs that they will have to screen one, two, three, or four other people who they have no such misgivings about in order to avoid seeming discriminatory (and avoid workplace or legal punishment). What effects will this have on security personnel? First, it will make them more likely to rationalize away misgivings or suspicions in order to avoid the hassle and risk that performing a search will require. Second, it wastes massive amounts of resources to "keep up appearances" by searching low-risk passengers in order to avoid a lawsuit from anyone who may or may not be higher-risk. I could go on but I don't want to focus too much on airport security when it's the principle I'm interested in discussing.

Why do I bring this up? Well, I just finished reading a very curious book entitled In Defense of Internment: The Case for 'Racial Profiling' in World War II and the War on Terror by Michelle Malkin. In other words, this book attempts to defend the relocation and internment of 112,000 ethnic Japanese, primarily from the West Coast, during WWII. I remember hearing about this in Jr. High and the impression I got was that it was not considered to be one of America's finest moments in history (especially given the way it was addressed in our textbook, which I still have - the authors used phrases like "herded together" "concentration camps" "unnecessary and unfair" "hysteria" "swell of...prejudice" "deprived these uprooted Americans of dignity and basic rights" etc.). Consequently my first impression of this book was "Wow, I bet that went over like a lead balloon." A visit to Amazon.com supported my initial evaluation: Of the books 150 reviews, 75 were for 1 star (though overall the book is rated 2.5/5 stars). But I must admit that such an unpopular and provocative undertaking piqued my curiosity, so I checked out the book from the library.

I found it to be fascinating. The author undertook the project after growing tired of hearing people repeatedly raise the infamous spectre of the Japanese internment to undercut many post-9/11 security measures. One civil rights spokesman she quotes as saying "The authorities should not target individuals based on their race, religion, or ethnicity" and that doing so would be "un-American." Another stated that some of the security measures target "people based on their ethnicity and not because they have done anything wrong." From a moral standpoint, I couldn't agree more. From a practical, defensive, survival standpoint, such an attitude is suicidally wrong, in my opinion.

One of the biggest problems in our history's account of the Japanese relocation and internment is that classified evidence, available to FDR and the people who orchestrated the relocation, was not available to anyone else. In fact, much of the evidence was gathered through a top-secret program that had broken a Japanese encryption system early in the war. That program provided valuable intelligence that, according to an Army official, was critical in the success of US naval engagements against the Japanese at Midway Island and the Coral Sea. It also provided large amounts of intelligence that indicated that Japan was establishing covert espionage networks in Hawaii, San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Seattle prior to and immediately following the Pearl Harbor attack. This information was not declassified until decades later, after the war was over with Japan defeated and its threat of a Pacific Coast invasion long debunked. Consequently, many of the conclusions historians have drawn about the Japanese internment reflect not only "hindsight bias" but also conclusions drawn from only part of the whole intelligence picture that the wartime decision makers were working from.

Photo of the crashed Zero fighter of Japanese Naval Airman Shigenori Nishikaichi on the Hawaiian island of Ni'ihau after the Pearl Harbor attack

Anyway, I've already gone on too long and there's no way I can discuss all of the amazingly well researched evidence in support of the strategic decision to remove ethnic Japanese from the most vulnerable and sensitive areas of our country in a war with their ethnic homeland. The book contains almost 150 pages of declassified military documents and intercepted transmissions showing Japan's attempts to establish spy rings and instigate "fifth column" activities along the Pacific Coast and in Hawaii. She also includes pictures of known Japanese spies as well as two ethnic Japanese who turned on their friends and neighbors to assist a downed Japanese pilot on the Hawaiian island of Ni'ihau after Pearl Harbor (read about the "Ni'ihau Incident" here). One of the poor reviews on Amazon.com follows the same faulty reasoning that Malkin exposes in her book - the writer, a descendant of Japanese Americans who were relocated, argues that the ethnic Japanese proved their loyalty to this country by serving valiantly in the European theater. That's true (and Malkin plainly acknowledges it), but it's also true that FDR and the decision makers didn't know that when they made the decision!

A map of the Ellwood Oil Field near Goleta, CA that was shelled by a Japanese submarine in 1942.

The point is that we were then, as we are now, in a war in which our enemies share certain characteristics: Religion (Shinto/Islam), Nationality (Japanese/Middle-Eastern or Muslim Nations), and a hatred for the United States. It's true, that some people who are not our enemies share two of these three characteristics. So we are left with a dilemma: Do we ignore these characteristics that highly correlate with our enemies in the War on Terror now, as they did in WWII then to avoid accusations of "racial profiling" or "ethnic discrimination?" It is true that the overwhelming majority of people who share the higher-risk characteristics are not our enemies, just as it was during WWII. But we've already seen the damage that a very small minority of that group can do. Only 7% of the 265 passengers and crew of the four 9/11 flights were terrorists, but that small minority did a tremendous amount of damage to the other 93% and so many others. Malkin nor I am advocating a new internment of Muslim/Middle-Eastern Americans, but we both strongly feel that the amount of political correctness that has handicapped our security personnel in this dangerous time may end up costing us our lives.

2 comments:

Liz said...

I can tell which person wrote which blog, just by the titles. Take the last two posts for example... :)

Sarady said...

Scott, I'm always so impressed with your research skills. I can't really comment too much because I'm not very knowledgable about these kinds of things, but I do agree that the airport security situation is kind of a joke.