Sunday, December 7, 2008

What's A Good Mechanic Worth?

To us? At least $500!

The check engine light has been on in our little Mazda for about 7-8 months now. During the Summer we broke down on a trip to Utah and had to be towed into town from Farmington by my parents. My dad took the car in to his mechanic and got us all fixed up (thanks again Dad!) so we could make it back to Idaho in one piece. At that time the mechanic informed us that our catalytic converter was "bad" and would need to be replaced in order to pass emissions. Since emissions was months away on the horizon we decided to pass.

Soon enough, we found ourselves at that horizon with the check engine light still on. We gave it a whirl and failed. The emissions tech told us what we already knew: It was our catalytic converter. For those of you who don't know, a catalytic converter is a mechanism that basically re-burns the exhaust from your engine at a super-high temperature so as to more completely break down and eliminate the harmful by-products of gasoline combustion. If that mechanism isn't working, your exhaust is too "toxic" and you won't pass emissions. I also learned that if your check engine light is on at all you automatically fail. Nice.

Diagram of a catalytic converter (the cheaper one)

So I started calling around to different places and was pleased to hear almost everyone I called mention that they do free inspections and estimates. What did not please me was that I also heard that our particular Mazda has TWO catalytic converters and that the failure could be in either one or both. And here's the kicker: To replace the rear converter it would cost around $150, but to replace the front converter (which was most likely the culprit)...$450-$750! OUCH! Just to pass emissions! Our car probably isn't worth $750!

Then a tiny miracle happened. The second mechanic we took the car to let us in on a little secret. He wiped the engine memory to turn off the check engine light and told me that he couldn't find anything very wrong with either converter. He said that these converters have a very fine mechanism in them that will trip on the check engine light if it crosses a line by even "this much" (he indicated a very small amount with his fingers). But what you can do is drive the car for around 75 miles (or about 15-20 ignition cycles), by which time the engine memory will have started accumulating data gain. However, the engine memory has to track a trend (like the catalytic converter switch) for about 25 miles before it will kick the light on. So we need to get back to the emissions tester at between 75-100 miles later and it should pass. He said that we couldn't take it back right away because the emissions test would note that the engine memory had just been wiped and we'd fail again automatically. But we had hope! A 25-mile window of hope!

And it worked! Hurrah for Walt's Auto Shop! We need to send that guy a fruit basket since he just saved us at least $500. Merry Christmas to us. Of course, we'll probably have to actually solve the problem by next fall, but by then hopefully we'll either have a new car or $500 saved up in anticipation of our date with emissions.

2 comments:

Sarady said...

That guy is an angel. Thank goodness for people like him out there. Don't you love the feeling of car troubles right around Christmas time? We just found out about a $650 repair that our poor '96 Infiniti needs; we'll probably hold off and regret it later.

Melissa said...

$500 is $500, so way to go! Good luck with car.