Wednesday, May 7, 2008

Oversimplification, anyone?


Here is a quote from a news story today:

Al Gore says that the cyclone in Myanmar is a result of global warming. He told NPR yesterday:
And as we’re talking today, Terry, the death count in Myanmar from the cyclone that hit there yesterday has been rising from 15,000 to way on up there to much higher numbers now being speculated. And last year a catastrophic storm from last fall hit Bangladesh. The year before, the strongest cyclone in more than 50 years hit China – and we’re seeing consequences that scientists have long predicted might be associated with continued global warming.

Gore said that because ocean temperatures are on the rise, extreme and dangerous weather is also on the rise.

That got me thinking about this website I found a while back that talked about the 10 most devastating hurricanes in US history. I remember them being spread out all over the last century and a half (about how long people were probably keeping detailed records of such things). So I decided to look into this a little bit more. Here's some of what I found:

1) The strongest hurricane ever measured in the the western hemisphere was Hurricane Gilbert in 1988. It had a central pressure of 888 millibars. The strongest Hurricane ever recorded worldwide was in the North Pacific in 1979 with a central pressure of 870 millibars. A lower millibar measurement signifies greater strength.

2) There have only ever been 3 Category 5 (winds of 155 mph or greater) to make landfall in the United States. Florida's "Labor Day" Hurricane in 1935 (892 millibars), Hurricane Camille in Mississippi in 1969 (909 millibars), and Hurricane Andrew in Florida in 1992 (922 millibars).

3) 8 of the 10 strongest hurricanes to hit the United States occurred before 1970. Half of them occurred before 1936. Hurricane Katrina is the second strongest hurricane to hit the US in terms of central pressure. However, Katrina reached it's peak strength while at sea, reaching Category 5 status before dropping to Category 3 status by the time it made landfall. Those tricky statistics - more on this later.

4) 10 of the 11 deadliest hurricanes to hit the United States occurred before 1958; Hurricane Katrina is the only one to occur since 1958. 7 of the 11 occurred before 1929. The deadliest US hurricane hit Galveston, Texas in 1900, resulting in the deaths of between 6,000 and 12,000 people. A hurricane that hit Florida in 1928 killed over 2,500 people. Hurricane Katrina's landfall in 2005 resulted in over 1,800 deaths.

5) 4 of the 5 deadliest hurricanes in the Pacific occurred before 1938. The other occurred in 1975, and caused a massive death toll due to record rainfall and the overwhelming of 62 dams across China.

6) Of the 10 deadliest Hurricanes worldwide, 5 occurred before 1883, and 9 of the 10 occurred before 1971.

You can check this stuff out yourself and more interesting facts at: http://www.epicdisasters.com/index.php/site/category/hurricanes/

*Important Lesson: By measuring hurricanes in terms of loss of life, you can't just assume that if the same hurricane were to occur today that it produce the same outcome (as I'm sure Al Gore would argue). If you do, you are committing one of the cardinal sins against good science, not to mention logic. To compare "apples to apples" when talking about deadly hurricanes, you have to factor in improved medicine, housing, and other technologies that have surely mitigated the loss of life in recent years. For example, a relatively weak hurricane in the days before penicillin and modern construction technology, would probably kill many fewer people were it to occur today. Consequently, the deadliest hurricanes average would be skewed toward the distant past, creating an unfair standard of comparison to hurricanes today that may be much stronger (thanks to global warming) but less deadly.

But the due diligence of good science/logic doesn't end there. You must also consider the dramatic increase in world population over this same time period by considering that in 1800 there were under 1 billion people on the entire planet. By 1900 that had increased to over 1.5 billion, and 2.5 billion by 1950, and over 6 billion today. That creates more victims for hurricanes, serving to somewhat counterbalance the technological and medical advances that would decrease the number of fatalities. There are loads of other factors, like changes in measurement practices and technology over the decades, as well as infinite meteorological variables that play into hurricane formation and intensity.

Here's an interesting blurb from Wikipedia on Christopher Landsea, formerly a research meteorologist with the Hurricane Research Division of Atlantic Oceanographic & Meteorological Laboratory at NOAA, and who is now the Science and Operations Officer at the National Hurricane Center. He is also a member of the American Geophysical Union and the American Meteorological Society. He earned his doctoral degree in Atmospheric Science at Colorado State University. He also used to be a member of the IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change), but withdrew because "the IPCC had become politicized and the leadership ignored his concerns."

In an interview on PBS, Christopher Landsea said "we certainly see substantial warming in the ocean and atmosphere over the last several decades on the order of a degree Fahrenheit, and I have no doubt a portion of that, at least, is due to greenhouse warming. The question is whether we're seeing any real increases in the hurricane activity." He went on to say "with the Atlantic hurricanes in particular, they're due to changes both in the ocean as well as the atmosphere. Just changing the ocean where it's a little bit warmer isn't sufficient." As for climate change affecting hurricane strength, Landsea said that global warming theories and numerical modeling suggest only that "hurricanes like Katrina and Rita may have been stronger due to global warming but maybe by one or two miles per hour."
See, this stuff to me is interesting. It just serves to reconfirm my suspicions that so many of these global warming soapboxers are drawing largely indefensible conclusions based on seriously incomplete or misunderstood relationships. It's like Harry Reid blaming the California wildfires last Summer on global warming. Before that became the convenient "catch-all" explanation for any environmental problem, people were forced to look at more than one variable to figure out how the planet worked. Not so nowadays. Thanks to Al Gore, we can reduce the complicated multivariate dynamics underlying anything from wildfires to hurricanes to anthropogenic CO2 emissions (a.k.a. Global Warming).

Normally, I wouldn't get so hot under the collar about people living in an illogical wonderland, but given that President Bush has signed a law abolishing Thomas Edison's incandescent light bulb by 2012, and that the cost of corn is going through the roof because we're trying to turn food into fuel for cars (which is, by comparison, horribly inefficient and uneconomical), I just have to speak out.

Alright, I have to go now. It's time for our weekly "The Bachelor"/"Beauty and the Geek" double-header and I've already been working on this for way too long. And sadly, I have spent so much time working on this, knowing full well that only one or two people are probably going to read it. I'm probably just still needing more venting time after that U of U commencement address that made me so furious.

4 comments:

Ilene and Zac Thatcher said...

Everyone blames everything on global warming like everyone used to blame everything on El Nino when we were kids. Nice. Our house is on 300 N 67 E in provo. If you remember where the washington mutual bank was on university, you turn in there and it's your first house on the left. Also, we found out we're having a girl! We don't have a name yet, but we figure we have four months to decide on one.

Anonymous said...

I read the whole thing! I'm so proud of myself. I love reading your posts. These natural disasters have been prophesied, and they will become more prevalent either way. It makes me realize I've got to get it together and bulk up my food storage & emergency supplies!

Anna Beal said...

I wish more people thought like you. Although I do agree that we consume too much energy these days and could really use some better judgement when it comes to our earth, I agree that all this "global warming" stuff is absolutely rediculous! And the fact that our government is doing dumb things like giving tax credits to the wealthy for buying hybrids and high effecient products is crazy! That whole light bulb thing is really dumb!

Sarady said...

Your post was so informative, and it shed a little more light on my already-existant issues with the politics of global warming and "Going Green." I agree with A&C. I need to get a move on my food storage, but not because Al G. said so.